Business Travel News EuropeBusiness Travel News Europe
Business Travel News Europe
  • NEWSOpen Menu
    • Accommodation
    • Air Travel
    • Ground Transport
    • Management
    • Meetings
    • On the Move
    • Payment & Expense
    • Sustainability
    • Technology
    • TMC & Distribution
    • Travel Procurement
    • Recent Issues
  • FEATURESOpen Menu
    • View All Features
  • CONVERSATIONSOpen Menu
    • Interviews and Q&As
    • Guest columns
    • Podcasts
    • VIEW ALL CONVERSATIONS
  • RESOURCESOpen Menu
    • The Traveller Experience Index
    • Spotlight Series: Air travel
    • Connected Content: The distribution report
    • Spotlight Series: Travel management companies
    • BTN Europe's 2023 Hotlist
    • Powered Up: The travel tech of today & tomorrow
    • The Future of Meetings
    • Smart Money: Cards, payments & expenses
    • The Journey Towards Sustainable Business Travel
    • Safety Measures: Risk, duty of care & wellbeing
    • Stepping It Up: Small & midsized travel programmes
    • Diversity, Equity & Inclusion in business travel
    • Business Travel Rebooted
    • New Horizons: The 2022 sourcing guide
    • Wheels in Motion
  • EVENTSOpen Menu
    • Webinars
    • Business Travel Show Europe
    • Business Travel Show Europe Kick Off
    • Business Travel Awards Europe
    • Business Travel Intelligence Summit Europe
    • Business Travel Accommodation Summit
    • Business Travel Tech Talk
    • Entertainment Travel Summit
    • Global Travel Risk Summit
    • Strategic Meetings Summit
    • Sustainable Business Travel Summit Europe
    • VIEW ALL EVENTS
  • SUBSCRIBE
  • NEWSOpen Menu
    • Accommodation
    • Air Travel
    • Ground Transport
    • Management
    • Meetings
    • On the Move
    • Payment & Expense
    • Sustainability
    • Technology
    • TMC & Distribution
    • Travel Procurement
    • Recent Issues
  • FEATURESOpen Menu
    • View All Features
  • CONVERSATIONSOpen Menu
    • Interviews and Q&As
    • Guest columns
    • Podcasts
    • VIEW ALL CONVERSATIONS
  • RESOURCESOpen Menu
    • The Traveller Experience Index
    • Spotlight Series: Air travel
    • Connected Content: The distribution report
    • Spotlight Series: Travel management companies
    • BTN Europe's 2023 Hotlist
    • Powered Up: The travel tech of today & tomorrow
    • The Future of Meetings
    • Smart Money: Cards, payments & expenses
    • The Journey Towards Sustainable Business Travel
    • Safety Measures: Risk, duty of care & wellbeing
    • Stepping It Up: Small & midsized travel programmes
    • Diversity, Equity & Inclusion in business travel
    • Business Travel Rebooted
    • New Horizons: The 2022 sourcing guide
    • Wheels in Motion
  • EVENTSOpen Menu
    • Webinars
    • Business Travel Show Europe
    • Business Travel Show Europe Kick Off
    • Business Travel Awards Europe
    • Business Travel Intelligence Summit Europe
    • Business Travel Accommodation Summit
    • Business Travel Tech Talk
    • Entertainment Travel Summit
    • Global Travel Risk Summit
    • Strategic Meetings Summit
    • Sustainable Business Travel Summit Europe
    • VIEW ALL EVENTS
  • SUBSCRIBE
Business Travel News Europe
  • Business Travel News Europe on Twitter
  • BTN Europe on LinkedIn
  • BTN Europe on Facebook
  • NEWS
    • Accommodation
    • Air Travel
    • Ground Transport
    • Management
    • Meetings
    • On the Move
    • Payment & Expense
    • Sustainability
    • Technology
    • TMC & Distribution
    • Travel Procurement
    • Recent Issues
    SubscribeBTN Europe NewsletterBTN Europe Magazine
  • FEATURES
    • View All Features
    BTN Europe traveller experience index cultural signalsCultural signals
    BTN Europe measuring the traveller experienceWhat is the measure of travel experience?
    BTN Europe traveller experience stop chasing the leisure experienceStop chasing the leisure experience

  • CONVERSATIONS
    • Interviews and Q&As
    • Guest columns
    • Podcasts
    • VIEW ALL CONVERSATIONS
    Interview: Bertrand Lacotte, board member, AFTMInterview: Bertrand Lacotte, board member, AFTM
    The ‘work from anywhere’ duty of care challengeThe ‘work from anywhere’ duty of care challenge
    Has China’s reopening lived up to the travel industry’s expectations?Has China’s reopening lived up to the travel industry’s expectations?
  • RESOURCES
    • The Traveller Experience Index
    • Spotlight Series: Air travel
    • Connected Content: The distribution report
    • Spotlight Series: Travel management companies
    • BTN Europe's 2023 Hotlist
    • Powered Up: The travel tech of today & tomorrow
    • The Future of Meetings
    • Smart Money: Cards, payments & expenses
    • The Journey Towards Sustainable Business Travel
    • Safety Measures: Risk, duty of care & wellbeing
    • Stepping It Up: Small & midsized travel programmes
    • Diversity, Equity & Inclusion in business travel
    • Business Travel Rebooted
    • New Horizons: The 2022 sourcing guide
    • Wheels in Motion
    Tools & ResourcesEurope's Leading TMCs 2022Booking tools – the essential guideTraveller Experience IndexTravel entry requirementsCorporate Travel Index EuropeBTN Europe podcastsBTSE Kick Off - CEO InterviewsRecent issues of BTN Europe
  • EVENTS
    • Webinars
    • Business Travel Show Europe
    • Business Travel Show Europe Kick Off
    • Business Travel Awards Europe
    • Business Travel Intelligence Summit Europe
    • Business Travel Accommodation Summit
    • Business Travel Tech Talk
    • Entertainment Travel Summit
    • Global Travel Risk Summit
    • Strategic Meetings Summit
    • Sustainable Business Travel Summit Europe
    • VIEW ALL EVENTS
    Business Travel Show Europe 2023

    28 - 29 June, ExCeL London

    4th Annual Business Travel Accommodations Summit Europe

    September 2023, In-Person

    7th Annual Global Travel Risk Summit Europe

    Global Travel Risk Summit Europe, September 2023,

  • SUBSCRIBE

Supreme Court Clears Travel Ban to Take Effect

By Elizabeth West / 5 December 2017 / Contact Reporter

Updated Dec. 4

The Supreme Court has granted the Department of Justice's request to allow President Donald Trump's latest travel ban to take effect throughout the appeals process. Trump ordered the ban Sept. 24, and two federal appeals courts are scheduled to hear arguments this week. The Supreme Court could hear further appeals down the line, however, and Monday decision allows the ban to take effect throughout that process. This interim decision is considered by some to be a litmus test for a potential future ruling by the Supreme Court. 


Posted Nov. 21, 2017

The Department of Justice has requested the Supreme Court to allow President Donald Trump's full travel ban to go into effect while it awaits oral arguments in California's Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals scheduled for Dec. 6. Hawaii District Judge Derrick Watson's previous ruling would have allowed citizens from Chad, Iran, Libya, Somalia, Syria and Yemen to travel to the U.S. without recognized family or local organizational relationships, but a three-judge panel on the Ninth Circuit Court put a partial stay on Watson's decision.

Trump's Sept. 24 proclamation tailored the scope of his previous travel bans to include the six countries above, but also placed fresh restrictions on North Korean travelers, for whom travel already was largely frozen, and certain government officials from Venezuela. The restrictions would have gone into effect on Oct. 18 but for Watson's ruling to stay the order for the six majority-Muslim countries, arguing that the proclamation failed to prove that these travelers were a threat to the U.S.

Maryland District Judge Theodore Chuang also ruled to stay Trump's order, arguing that the order amounted to little more than religious discrimination against Muslims. He nevertheless narrowed the scope of his stay to travelers with a bona fide family relationship—previously identified as a parent, grandparent, son, daughter, cousin, aunt or uncle—or a documented relationship with a U.S. entity, such as a business, university or resettlement agency.

Neither judge challenged the ban for North Korea or Venezuela.

California's Ninth District Court last week took the same tack as Chuang when reviewing the DOJ's appeal of Watson's stay, ruling that the ban should be allowed to stand for travelers who lacked an established relationship in the U.S. Those with a bona fide relationship, however, should be allowed to travel to the U.S. during the appeals process, according to the circuit court.

Conversely, the DOJ has asked the Supreme Court to clear the travel ban to take full effect for all eight countries until the Ninth Circuit can rule on the case. The Trump administration says the current travel ban is "cured" of any potential "animus" toward any particular religion and is based on a full review of travel security thresholds in the eight identified countries.

The fact that the lower-court decisions hinge on the "bona fide relationship" aspect could be key. The Supreme Court introduced that mitigating language this summer when it cleared President Trump's second travel ban to take partial effect while the opposing parties prepared for oral arguments scheduled for October. Those arguments never took place, as the Supreme Court determined the case to be moot once Trump issued the proclamation for the third version of the ban in late September.

The court had hinted it expected a resolution on the previous travel ban prior to having to take up the case. The previous order had a 90-day expiration date that would have nearly run its course by the time the court was scheduled to hear arguments. The current travel ban has no expiration.

In asking once again for the Supreme Court to allow the ban to proceed during an appeals process, the Trump administration may be testing the waters for a more definitive decision should the case ultimately proceed to the high court.

More

SPONSORED CONTENT

The workplace has changed. Does your travel & expense match up?
The workplace has changed. Does your travel & expense match up?By Cytric by Amadeus

Does your travel & expense match up?... KEEP READING

The eight trends shaping ground transportation
The eight trends shaping ground transportationBy Enterprise National

Eight emerging ground transportation priorities shaping business travel in 2022 and beyond... KEEP READING

  • Most Read
  • Most Shared
  1. Winners of inaugural Business Travel Sustainability Awards Europe announced
  2. London remains top European city for meetings and events
  3. France formally bans some domestic flights
  4. Independent TMCs ‘outperforming’ the wider market
  5. Heathrow faces summer disruption as pay dispute ‘escalates’
Business Travel News EuropeBusiness Travel News Europe
  • About us
  • Contact us
  • Advertise
  • EDITORIAL CALENDAR
  • Business Travel Show Europe
  • Business Travel News Europe on Twitter
  • BTN Europe on LinkedIn
  • BTN Europe on Facebook
BUSINESS TRAVEL NEWS EUROPE
NORTHSTAR TRAVEL GROUP
Business Travel News
  • About us
  • Contact us
  • Advertise
  • Editorial calendar
  • Editorial guidelines
  • Subscribe to BTN Europe
  • Subscribe to BTN U.S.
  • Subscribe to Travel Procurement
  • Privacy policy
  • Terms & conditions
Northstar Travel Group
  • Corporate travel
  • Business Travel Show
  • Business Travel Awards
  • BTN U.S.
  • The Beat
  • Travel Procurement

  • Travel Technology
  • Travel Tech Show
  • Phocuswire
  • Phocuswright
  • Intelliguide
  • Meetings & incentives
  • M&IT
  • AMI
  • ConventionSource
  • M&IT Awards

  • Retail travel
  • Travel Weekly
  • Travel Pulse

  • Northstar Travel Group
  • View all Northstar brands
BTNGroup
Business Travel News EuropeBusiness Travel NewsTravel ProcurementThe BeatBusiness Travel Show Europe
Northstar Travel Group
Copyright ©2022, Northstar Travel Media Ltd, The Epworth, 25 City Road, London EC1Y 1AA, UK
RRManagement rrtestprocurement